Meet Our Staff

As our client, you will have a team of highly qualified professionals working for you to provide you with the best coverage for you, your family, or your business.  Building a long-lasting relationship with our clients is our number one priority.

Joel Weis

Agent/ Sec/ Owner
Fax: (262) 763-5080
Office: 26276324081020
Mobile: (262) 716-3222

James Peterson

Agent/ Treas/ Owner
Fax: (262) 763-5080
Office: 26276324081025
Mobile: (262) 716-6585

Jim Peterson is a Licensed Insurance Agent in Property & Casualty and Health, Life & Accident Insurance. He is one of our experts in Commercial Liability & Property Insurance as well as Group Health Insurance. Although Jim is young at heart, he brings a wealth of knowledge and experience to our May’s Insurance Agency family by being one of the senior partners/owners. Jim is currently a member of the City of Burlington Fire Department and is celebrating his 42nd year serving as a volunteer fireman. He is also a Kiwanis member (since 1975) and Past President.

Some Interesting Facts about Jim Peterson include:
UW – Whitewater graduate in 1970, Worked at the Bank of Burlington in 1978 before starting his career at May’s, Was on the Burlington High School State Champion Basketball Team, He is an avid golf player and loves spending time with his grandchildren.

Michael Deans

Agent/ Vice President/ Owner
Fax: (262) 763-5080
Office: 26276324081030
Mobile: (262) 716-6560

Mike Deans is a Licensed Insurance Agent in Property & Casualty and Health, Life & Accident Insurance. Mike currently has professional memberships in both the Professional Insurance Agents of Wisconsin (PIAW) & the Big I as a “Trusted Choice” Independent Agent. Although his specialty is in Personal Lines products like Homeowners, Auto, Personal Liability & Life Insurance, Mike is also has extensive knowledge in Business & Commercial Insurance.

Mike is active in Burlington Rotary, a Commissioner on the City of Burlington Planning Commission, Veterans Memorial Day Parade Chairman, Burlington Gridiron Officer, Burlington Community Education Flag Football Commissioner, and currently coaches for Burlington Little League.

Some interesting facts about Mike Deans include:
Undergraduate Degree in ESS-Physical Education (UW-La Crosse), Masters Degree in Sport Administration (UW-La Crosse), Former All-Conference Middle Linebacker for University of WI-La Crosse (1994-1998) Former Linebackers Assistant Coach for University of Wisconsin – La Crosse (2000-2002) Former Head Football Coach for South Milwaukee High School (2002-2005) Former Assistant Varsity Football Coach for Burlington High School (2006-2011)

Alice Busch

Commercial Lines Account Executive
Direct: (262) 342-1022
Fax: (262) 763-5080
Office: 26276324081022

Alice Busch is our Commercial Lines Account Executive and is licensed in Property & Casualty Insurance, as well as Health, Life & Disability Insurance. She also holds the distinguished Certified Insurance Counselor or CIC designation. There is no doubt that Alice is one of the most experienced and knowledgeable insurance professionals in the Burlington area. Equally impressive is her long list of volunteerism in Burlington and Racine County. From her work with Love Incorporated (meal site) to a Leader in the Burlington Back 40 4-H Club, Alice continues her tradition of helping people. She also devotes much of her time each year in the Youth building at Racine county Fair.

Alice has had a long and distinguished career at Mays Insurance Agency. She began her employment at Mays in January, 1973. She has worked in every internal department here including her time as our Personal Lines Manager, then moved in to our Life & Health area. At last, she found her ‘sweet spot’ in Commercial Lines where she has been since 1997.

Interesting details about Alice Busch include
Her joy of reading, sewing doll clothes and other crafts; and most especially, Alice loves to spend time with her family and friends!

Gayle Koch

Personal Lines Customer Service Agent- Processing
Direct: (262) 342-1032
Fax: (262) 763-5080
Office: 26276324081032

Mona Schuerman

Personal Lines Customer Service Agent- Sales
Direct: (262) 342-1032
Fax: (262) 763-5080
Office: (262) 763-2408

Peggy Weidert

Bookkeeping
Fax: (262) 763-5080
Office: (262) 763-2408

Peggy Weidert is the newest member of our Mays Insurance Agency Team hired in August of 2012 as our Bookkeeper. Although most of what Peggy does is behind the scenes, she is a critically important part of the Mays family! She brings over 15 years of bookkeeping and recordkeeping experience with her. Her previous work experiences include 20 years at Tripco Travel (last 10 years as co-owner). Peggy has a love for “crunching numbers” and takes pleasure in balancing the check book! How about that!

Interesting facts about Peggy Weidert include:

She was a born and raised Burlington and graduated from BHS in 1981. Peggy also married her highschool sweatheart, Chris Weidert, Owner of Weidert Electric in 1985. She continues to raise her three wonderful boys and thoroughly enjoys watching them play sports. Her hobbies/ interests include her time up at their family property in Northern Wisconsin, watching old movies (like It’s A Wonderful Life), bowling, Sudoku puzzles, Working outside at her home mowing the lawn & passing the time in her flower garden

A Special note about Peggy and William (Bill) Weidert
Peggy and the Weidert family have a special and significant place in the history of Mays Insurance Agency, too! Peggy’s late father-in-law, William Weidert, was himself a vital part of the Mays legacy. William (Bill) Weidert was a former agency Owner and Agent of Mays Insurance Agency. In his life, Bill was truly a hometown hero . From his military service to our county as a Navy man during World War II, to his selflessness as a longtime member of the Burlington Rescue Squad; Bill was a man that was so much more than just an exceptional insurance professional and prominent Burlington business owner. He was a remarkable person that exemplifies what May’s Insurance Agency has always stood for. William Weidert will be remembered for his vast knowledge, unwavering integrity, service above one’s self and family. Rest in Peace.

Sarah Boylen

Health & Life Account Executive
Direct: (262) 342-1021
Fax: (262) 763-5080
Office: 26276324081021

Sarah Boylen is a Licensed Agent in Health, Life & Accident Insurance, as well as Property & Casualty Insurance. She is also our Health & Life Insurance Account Executive. Sarah is currently on the Burlington Area Chamber of Commerce – Annual Auction Dinner Committee, which is one of the largest annual fundraisers for the Burlington Area Chamber of Commerce (BACC)

Sarah started her career at May’s Insurance Agency in 2008. Her previous work experience was at Minuteman Press as a Graphic Designer here in Burlington. Sarah earned her BFA Undergraduate degree majoring in Art with a Multimedia Design Concentration from University of Wisconsin- Stout (1998-2003).

Some interesting facts about Sarah Boylen are:
Sarah didn’t have any idea that she would end up in insurance growing up, especially after wanting to be a Veterinarian and then a Graphic Designer. But much to her surprise, after she made the career change, Health Insurance is an area that she has come to enjoy. It is obvious to anyone who meets with Sarah, that she is not only extremely knowledgeable in Individual & Group Health Insurance, but she is an expert in helping people manage their individual and business health insurance risks!

Nicole Baumeister

Commercial Lines Customer Service Agent
Direct: (262) 955-8738
Fax: (262) 955-8735
Office: (262) 763-2408

Ashley Bahr

Personal Lines Customer Service Agent-Sales
Direct: 26276324081095
Fax: (262) 763-5080
Office: (262) 763-2408